Tikah, my hunter, is currently my Herbalist/Alchemist. It made sense to me at the time that I started it.. but in play I’ve found this combination has issues.
A herbalist gathers flowers. The flowers live in bag slots. Bag slots that could be used for other inventory. This limits the player’s inventory. If you get a herbalist bag then it takes up a whole bag slot.
A hunter shoots arrows. Arrows live in bag slots. You get a 10% bonus if the arrows live in a quiver. The quiver takes up a bag slot further limiting the amount of inventory available to the hunter for non-arrow inventory.
A hunter can track critters (humans, undead, beasts, etc). While a hunter is tracking critters she can’t track flowers (or ore deposits). The one-thing-at-a-time thing is really annoying and limits the hunter’s effectiveness either as a hunter or as an herbalist.
Therefore I’ve decided that my hunter needs to -not- be a herbalist/alchemist. That said, my other characters are getting a ton of usefulness from the potions so I’m not willing to -not- have a herbalist/alchemist character.
I thought about this for a while and decided to start a new Night Elf Druid (Hybrid Spellcaster/Tank so that she can fend for herself). The new druid will pick flowers and turn them into potions. She’ll also skill up fishing since some fish are used in some potions. She’ll also skill up in First Aid enough to use the appropriate bandages.
When the druid’s herbalism/alchemy reaches Tikah’s current level then I’ll re-do Tikah to be a skinner/leatherworker. This was a hard choice.
It seems silly to me to have two leatherworkers.. but since a hunter won’t work as a gatherer toon (and it seems silly to waste a profession) I’ll instead update her to make leather goods. When Tikah’s Skinning/Leatherworking reaches Tikataka’s current leatherworking level then I’ll redo Tikataka to do Skinning/Herbalism. There doesn’t seem to be any issue with a rogue gatherer.
|Tikataka||Skinning / Leather working||Skinning / Herbalism||Skill up enough to bandage self||Will send leather to Tikah, cloth to Monneh, and plants to new druid|
|Tikah||Herbalism / Alchemy||Skinning / Leather working||Good for feeding pet||Good for feeding pet||Skill up enough to bandage self||Will send cloth to Monneh. Send leather goods to Tikataka.|
|Monneh||Tailoring / Enchanting||Tailoring / Enchanting||Skill up full to make bandages for everyone. Good for bandaging self w/o using mana||Not in love with these professions. Hopefully skilling up will make it more obviously useful. Send bags and bandages to everyone.|
|New Druid||Herbalism / Alchemy||Good for potions||Skill up enough to bandage self||Send cloth to Monneh. Send potions to everyone.|
I doubt you care.. but I do.. and I wanted to get it all written down so I wouldn’t forget.